Is the reservation system in India fair after an MBBS?
The reservation system in India is a boon for many while a curse for some. However, it is believed that a reservation system in higher education, especially after MBBS, leads to the compromise in the quality of education along with seizing a worthy opportunity from the hands of deserving candidates
1.5K Views|11 Followers|Posted 2015-09-03 16:56:20
Started by Prateek Sengar
11 Comments
Commented by
a year ago
In some cases, reservation system is useful i.e. in registration fees of some exams. But reservation system should be according to the financial circumstances not according to the caste system. And after MBBS, we should prefer those who have better skills and knowledge.
Upvote 
A
Commented by
9 years ago
Reservation will automatically will become undesirable if Leadership seed cultivation training is introduced before joining any instt./professional course.
I think time has arrived that after 12th 1st step should be to pass thru' Leadership Seed Cultivation training. This will help them in realising
Upvote 
Commented by
9 years ago
its an undue advantage given to some people. needs lots of correction in this system.percentage of reservation for SC and STs should be reduced by some more figures.
Upvote 
Commented by
9 years ago
Reservation is like partiality between the two class of people in society . Rich gets benefit n Poor remains uneducated.
Upvote 
Commented by
2016-04-30 13:59:45
Not at all... Not only in medical field but also in other fields too... It just a way to get seat in the clgs which are under many rich people nd several authorities but what about those students who r best in studies but unfortunately belongs to a middle class or low class families ??? Reservation
Upvote 
Commented by
2015-09-08 14:45:26
I think reservation should be caught and throughout from our nation first of all it killing talent, it killing healthy competition, it promoting corruption, murder.and so on.
so from my point of view reservation is not good after MBBS or any other.
Upvote 
Commented by
2015-09-03 17:26:00
Hi All,
I think reservation should be abolished at the higher education level because it does impact the quality of students passing out and when you are attaining specialization, it should be purely on the merit and skills basis.
Upvote 1 Reply
2015-09-03 17:30:10
Well said Shruti, if you are becoming a specialist that too in a medical profession , you should attain it purely on your capabilities because otherwise you will be putting somebody's life at risk.
Commented by
2015-09-03 17:18:01
Hi,
VOTE BANK of the political parties drives reservation system in India and the actual cause of the reservation is often neglected
Upvote Commented by
2015-09-03 17:12:58
Reservation only helps in securing a seat in the college and if the candidate does not perform in studies in the college , he will be thrown out automatically because there is no reservation in the college examinations.
So, only those candidates who are deserving ends up with a degree
Upvote Commented by
2015-09-03 17:08:16
Hey Everyone,
Its not about reservation at higher education or at the UG level, it should be about whether the benefits of the reservation is reaching out to the right person or not because the whole idea of reservation is of no use if its provided to the person who actually doesn't need it.
Upvote Commented by
2015-09-03 17:02:42
Hi All,
Reservation should only be provided to those who are economically backward and can't afford quality education . Government should make stringent laws regarding reservation and implement the same because the benefits of reservation does not reach the right person.
Upvote Taking an Exam? Selecting a College?
Get authentic answers from experts, students and alumni that you won't find anywhere else.
On Shiksha, get access to
66K
Colleges
|
1.2K
Exams
|
6.9L
Reviews
|
1.9M
Answers
Didn't find the answer you were looking for?
Search from Shiksha's 1 lakh+ Topics
or
Ask Current Students, Alumni & our Experts
Have a question related to your career & education?
or
See what others like you are asking & answering